And what did you think? I'm thinking about getting it for PC, but have heard it's not what was expected, so not sure if I want to spend the money or not. On the other hand, the challenge of making them live and survive on an island appeals to the tyrant in me!

I purchased the game for PS2, and I have yet to play it. There really is no reason for not playing, I just haven't done it. I have spoken to a few people who really like it, but a couple thought it was just ok. I MUST get that game in the console and play.

I have both versions, I would say wait for a sale before you get the PC version bluesim, its not worth full price, It is good, but its not great and its not worth what they are asking.
The console game I really really enjoy I though about doing a little walkthrough thinhy for it, but i'm still learning my way through it

A buddy of mine got the PC version. She thinks its great. Still need to try it out.

I have the game for PSP, and I regret the buy. Its fun and all, but like Gravey said, its not worth full price. I'm almost done with it actually. I think for all Castaway and Console games you really need the patience.